Logo
Listing Category

Bartlett Benner Realty, based in Lancaster, Ohio, is a traditional, full-service brokerage with deep roots across Fairfield, Hocking, and the surrounding counties. Our team blends classic real-estate values with modern tools, serving homeowners, buyers, and investors with the kind of honest, dependable service this region has always been built on.

We have a strong footprint in the Hocking Hills lodging community, representing both residential sellers and a growing portfolio of short-term rental properties. From marketing, guest communication, and property oversight to full sales representation for cabins, homes, and investment properties, we provide owners with steady, straightforward support they can count on.

Whether you’re operating a STR, listing a cabin, or looking for the right investment in one of Ohio’s most-loved destinations, Bartlett Benner Realty is committed to helping you protect your asset, maximize its potential, and uphold the quality and hospitality Hocking Hills is known for.

Business Phone
740-654-1500

Real Estate Sales & Representation

Full-service residential listing and buyer representation

Detailed market analysis and pricing strategy

Professional marketing, photography, and MLS exposure

Contract negotiation and transaction oversight

Land, acreage, and rural property expertise

Investment property acquisition support

Short-Term Rental (STR) Management

Full-service management for Airbnb/VRBO/Eviivo properties

Guest communication, screening, and support

Dynamic pricing strategy and occupancy monitoring

Cleaning team coordination and turnover management

Restocking, supply tracking, and quality control

Review management and guest experience optimization

STR Launch & Setup

Property readiness and furnishing guidance

Listing creation and optimization on all major booking platforms

Safety compliance review (smoke alarms, egress, signage, etc.)

Photography coordination and staging assistance

Owner onboarding and revenue projections

Marketing & Branding for STR Owners

Custom branding for cabins (names, logos, signage)

Social media marketing and property highlight posts

Custom brochures, welcome books, and guest messaging templates

Local tourism positioning and visibility strategy

Owner Support & Reporting

Monthly financial summaries

Maintenance coordination and contractor referral network

On-call support for urgent guest or property needs

Transparent communication and consistent updates

Investment & Portfolio Consulting

STR revenue forecasting and comp analysis

Long-term rental evaluation

Guidance on expanding or optimizing an existing portfolio

Advice on cabin builds, modular homes, land development, and STR zoning considerations

Leave a Google Review URL
Contact Name
Keith Dwyer
  • Deer Cabin
  • Bakers Hillside Meadows
  • Quiet Pines
  • Pine Retreat
  • The Chieftain